Potential Trigger/Offense Warning. In this entry, there is some discussion of bullying, also, all “yous” are general.
Alternate Title: “Since When are we an ‘Us?’”
When I write about fandom stuff, I say that I don’t identify with the social justice leg of fandom. That means that I don’t give a fuck about some fictional black person working at McDonald’s, about what it says about me as a black person, et cetera, et cetera, and this is true. I really don’t think that someone’s depiction of an imaginary black person in a world that does not exist is really any reflection on me.
When I write about non-fandom stuff, while I get behind the idea of a given movement, while I get that, there’s something that always has bothered me.
That is the concept of “us”.
When people talk about “they” or “us”, I always wonder, “since when are we an ‘us’?”. And the answer I get when I actually ask this person a question is, “well, we’re both black people” or “well, we’re both women” or “well, we’re both something other than straight”. ….Well, yeah, that’s true. But the problem is that although I am a woman who is bisexual and black, my life experiences do not match up to the idea of what my experience should be or should have been. The problem I see, both within given social justice movements and outside of them, is the conflation of similarity and symmetry. That is, the assumption that because I belong to Group X, my feelings, thoughts, and experiences will neatly match up with those also belonging to Group X by virtue of my being (black, a woman, et cetera, et cetera). It’s the opposite of “othering”, and to me it’s just as bad to “us” people on two levels. One, by “ussing” people, it effectively negates their thoughts, feelings, experiences–their entire lives–and try to fit it all into this one thing based on the color of someone’s skin or the shape of their body or whatever else one can think of. Two, and this bothers me about a lot of things where it’s the same kind of bullshit people claim to be fighting, under the guise of something that should be a good idea (and oh, I have words about the lauding of masculine traits in women to the denigration of feminine traits in anybody), is that it’s harder to fight it without seeming like a tool because it’s couched in language that is supposed to be “good”. So I can’t ask, “Hold the fuck on, since when did I become part of your ‘us’?” because if I do that, the implication is that I have internalized (fill in the blank), which is a term that is so overused that it’ll take another post to articulate fully why that bothers me. But, as I was saying, it makes you look good to fight othering, but there is no right way to fight “ussing” because when someone ~standing up for me~ is trying to shove my experiences into this neat little box that they can make sense of, that’s somehow okay because their heart’s in the right place.
And to use an example, I have endured bullying for much of my life, in multiple forms. While it did leave me hurt, it also left me very angry, and that anger, also because of issues I have developed over many years of being Pentecostal, manifests as what some people think of as “hurt”. I become extremely withdrawn and I am prone to beating myself up and blaming myself for things that probably aren’t really my fault. So when I see on the news, and hear people talk about how painful it is for kids who are bullied, while my heart goes out to them and I really do get why it’d hurt, I also don’t get why the only acceptable, media-palatable reaction to being dumped on is to bravely soldier on while people remark on how brave (general) you are, or try their damnedest to make the bullying stop by changing what makes them a target, or die if they can’t. And that fills me with The Fury for so many reasons. Not the least of which being that I don’t feel like I have the right to my anger. Because anger is “bad” and belongs to the perpetrator and not the victim…Apparently. I have this working theory that, generally, people see anger as the domain of perpetrators. Anger is the person who beats their spouse because they had a shitty day at work, or the parent who screams at their children for the slightest infraction. And Anger is bad and bullies have anger. Those who are bullied apparently don’t have the right to anger, because anger is what their tormentors have. Which is so much bullshit, and there’ll probably be a blog entry for that.
So I don’t get the idea of an “us”. I don’t get the idea of a universal black experience (made all the more insulting because I was told through my entire life that I don’t have a right to be part of the Universal Black Experience ™ because I was not “black enough”, whatever the flying fuck that means). I don’t get why othering is bad but ussing is just fine because “people’s hearts are in the right place”. And I still don’t get why the desire to at least scream at the people who’ve done me wrong makes me the same as those people.
The point is, similarity is not symmetry. And I will repeat that until everyone, especially the people “on my side” get it.